Why High Earners Still Don’t Feel Rich—and What Investors Must Do Differently Now
It’s a paradox that’s quietly reshaping the financial landscape: earning a high income no longer guarantees financial peace of mind or a robust nest egg. According to 2023 U.S. Census data, about 14% of American households bring in $200,000 or more annually. Yet many of these earners—dubbed “HENRYs” (High Earners, Not Rich Yet)—find themselves trapped in a cycle of stress, debt, and lifestyle inflation that keeps them from feeling truly wealthy.
A recent survey by BHG Financial reveals a startling insight: nearly 62% of those earning over $300,000 annually grapple with credit card debt. This isn’t just a statistic; it’s a wake-up call for investors and advisors alike. The traditional assumption that a hefty paycheck automatically translates into financial security is outdated. Even those pulling six-figure salaries often live paycheck to paycheck, caught in a spending treadmill that outpaces their income growth.
Why Does This Happen? The Psychology Behind the Paycheck
Clinical psychologist Sabrina Romanoff nails it: “Earning doesn’t actually make you feel rich; spending it does.” The emotional satisfaction often comes not from the number in your bank account but from the lifestyle your money supports. When you’re in accumulation mode—focused on building wealth—it’s hard to feel rich because your spending is intentionally restrained. This psychological disconnect fuels the “HENRY” phenomenon.
Adding fuel to the fire, a 2024 Bankrate survey found that Americans believe they need to earn an average of $520,000 annually to feel rich. This threshold rises with income: those making under $50,000 think $157,000 is comfortable, while those earning $100,000 or more say they need $246,000. This “comfort inflation” means that as income rises, so do expectations—and expenses.
A Real-Life Example: The Composer-Turned-Entrepreneur
Take Marie Incontrera, a 39-year-old former professional musician who pivoted to entrepreneurship. Her business revenue is projected at $1.4 million in 2025, with an owner’s draw of $300,000 to $400,000. Yet, despite this financial leap from $15,000 a year as a musician to hundreds of thousands as a business owner, she admits to feeling more financial anxiety now than ever.
“I feel privileged, but I do not feel rich,” she says. Her candid admission highlights a crucial lesson: wealth is as much about mindset and financial habits as it is about income.
What Investors and Advisors Need to Do Differently
-
Prioritize Value-Based Budgeting
Kamila Elliott, CEO of Collective Wealth Partners, emphasizes that budgets should reflect personal values. High earners must identify one or two discretionary spending areas that truly matter to them and redirect the rest into savings or investments. This strategy can break the cycle of lifestyle creep and build genuine wealth. -
Focus on Debt Management—Even for High Earners
The prevalence of credit card debt among high earners is alarming. Advisors should proactively address debt reduction strategies with clients, regardless of income level. High interest debt can erode wealth faster than many realize. -
Reframe the Definition of ‘Rich’
The pursuit of an ever-higher income target to feel “rich” is a moving goalpost. Investors should shift focus from chasing higher paychecks to enhancing financial security through diversified investments, passive income streams, and smart tax planning. -
Prepare for Economic Uncertainty
With inflationary pressures and economic shifts continuing, even high earners face volatility. Building a robust emergency fund and maintaining liquidity is critical to avoid the stress that comes from living paycheck to paycheck.
Unique Insight: The New Wealth Metric—Financial Freedom Over Income
At Extreme Investor Network, we argue that the real measure of wealth today isn’t annual income but financial freedom—the ability to sustain your lifestyle without active work. For example, a recent study by Fidelity Investments found that 45% of millionaires prioritize passive income sources over salary growth. This shift signals a new paradigm where wealth is defined by autonomy, not just affluence.
What’s Next?
Investors and advisors must embrace a holistic approach that integrates psychology, disciplined spending, and strategic wealth-building. The “HENRY” phenomenon isn’t just a financial issue—it’s a cultural and behavioral one. By helping clients recalibrate their relationship with money and focus on sustainable wealth, advisors can unlock a new level of financial well-being for high earners who feel stuck.
In conclusion, don’t just chase the paycheck—chase financial freedom. That’s the future of wealth, and it’s a message only Extreme Investor Network delivers with the depth and insight you won’t find anywhere else.
Source: Why high-earning Americans do not feel rich