Eli Manning’s Exit from Giants Ownership Race: What It Reveals About Sports Franchise Valuations and Investor Strategies
Eli Manning, the legendary former New York Giants quarterback, recently dropped out of the race to buy a minority stake in his old team, candidly admitting to CNBC Sport that the price tag was simply too steep. “A 1% stake valued at $10 billion turns into a very big number,” Manning said—putting a spotlight on the unprecedented surge in sports franchise valuations that’s reshaping investment opportunities in professional sports.
The Billion-Dollar Barrier: Why Sports Franchises Are Skyrocketing in Value
According to CNBC’s Official NFL Team Valuations from September, the Giants were valued at $7.85 billion, ranking fourth among NFL teams. Yet, just months later, minority stakes in teams like the Philadelphia Eagles and San Francisco 49ers have been sold at valuations exceeding $8 billion. The Eagles’ recent minority stake sale valued the team at $8.3 billion, nearly $1 billion above CNBC’s earlier estimate, while the 49ers’ deal pegged their valuation at over $8.5 billion. Meanwhile, the NBA’s Los Angeles Lakers agreed to sell a majority stake at a staggering $10 billion valuation, a massive leap from the $7 billion valuation reported earlier in the year.
This rapid escalation is not just a sports story—it’s a wake-up call for investors and advisors. The market for sports franchises is entering a new phase where traditional valuation metrics are being supplemented by brand strength, media rights deals, and global fan engagement. For investors, this means the bar for entry is higher than ever, but the potential for long-term capital appreciation remains compelling.
What This Means for Investors and Advisors
-
Reassess Entry Strategies: For most investors, buying direct stakes in top-tier sports franchises like the Giants is becoming prohibitively expensive. However, the NFL’s recent decision to allow private equity firms to own up to 10% stakes opens new avenues for indirect investment. Advisors should explore partnerships with private equity funds specializing in sports assets, which can offer diversified exposure without the need for massive capital outlays.
-
Look Beyond the Major Leagues: Manning’s minority ownership in the National Women’s Soccer League’s Gotham FC and the TGL’s New York golf team highlights a growing trend—investing in emerging sports leagues and franchises that have lower valuations but significant growth potential. These markets can offer earlier entry points and diversification benefits.
-
Consider Media and Content Synergies: Manning’s withdrawal also underscores the complexities of conflicts of interest, especially for athletes turned broadcasters or content creators. Investors should carefully evaluate how ownership stakes might intersect with media rights, endorsements, and personal brand strategies. For example, owning stakes in teams while simultaneously working in sports media can create ethical and operational challenges.
-
Prepare for Continued Valuation Volatility: The sports franchise market is experiencing rapid valuation shifts driven by media deals, sponsorship growth, and fan engagement innovations like NFTs and metaverse experiences. Investors must be ready for volatility and should approach these assets with a long-term horizon, focusing on franchises with strong management and innovative growth strategies.
Unique Insight: The Rise of Fractional Ownership and Fan Engagement
One emerging trend not widely covered is the rise of fractional ownership platforms and fan tokens, which allow everyday investors to buy smaller stakes or participate in the economic upside of sports franchises. Companies like FTX (before its collapse) and Socios have pioneered fan tokens, creating new revenue streams and engagement models. While traditional ownership stakes remain out of reach for most, these innovations democratize access and could reshape how fans and investors interact with teams.
What’s Next?
For advisors and investors, the key takeaway is to monitor evolving league policies—like the NFL’s private equity allowance—and to diversify sports-related investments beyond marquee franchises. The market’s rapid growth is exciting but demands nuanced strategies that balance valuation realities with emerging opportunities in media, technology, and alternative sports leagues.
Eli Manning’s decision is more than a personal choice—it’s a cautionary tale and a signal of a maturing, complex market. The days of affordable sports franchise stakes are fading, but savvy investors who adapt to these trends can still find meaningful growth opportunities in the sports ecosystem.
Sources:
- CNBC Official NFL Team Valuations, September 2023
- Sportico, May 2024 reports on NFL minority stake bids
- Bloomberg on NBA franchise valuations and ownership trends
Actionable Advice:
- Financial advisors should educate clients on the risks and rewards of sports franchise investments, emphasizing long-term horizons and diversification.
- Explore private equity funds and emerging sports leagues as alternative entry points.
- Stay informed about league policy changes and innovations in fan engagement technologies that could unlock new investment opportunities.
By understanding these dynamics, investors can position themselves to capitalize on one of the most exciting frontiers in alternative assets today.
Source: Eli Manning not interested in ownership bid