Did Jim Cramer Get These 10 Predictions Right or Wrong? A Closer Look
In our recent analysis, we dive into Jim Cramer’s insights from the latest episode of Mad Money and explore how well those insights hold up against actual stock performance, specifically focussing on Maplebear Inc. (NASDAQ:CART).
During the episode that aired on May 12, Jim Cramer tackled the significance of the recent market rally. With renewed optimism following a trade agreement between the United States and China, he urged his audience to maintain their investments:
“Earnings matter again, okay? That’s what happened last night when the United States and China reached an agreement, however temporary, to hold off trade armageddon. The rollback of the exorbitant tariffs to much more reasonable levels caused the stock market to explode.”
While Cramer celebrated the uplift in market conditions, he also noted a critical point: the S&P 500 remains stagnant on a year-to-date basis. Further observations revealed that international markets, particularly in Europe, are outperforming:
“Now don’t get me wrong, I’m glad it happened, but I just spent a week in Europe, and it is stunning how much better the markets are doing over there.”
His overall message was clear: play the long game and resist the urge to time the market. As he stated:
“Bottom line: It’s better to stay in, stay on, and let her ride than to try to pick the perfect moment to trade in and out and in and out of the stock market. That’s not much of a strategy. It’s more of a game of chicken where there are no winners, just losers who think they are smarter than the average bear.”
Tracking Jim Cramer’s Stock Picks
For this analysis, we compiled a list of the 10 stocks discussed by Jim Cramer on May 13, 2024, and monitored their performance through May 13, 2025. This includes data on hedge fund sentiment from Insider Monkey’s Q4 2024 database, showcasing the stocks in the order they were mentioned.
What Makes Hedge Funds Tick?
Understanding why hedge funds invest in specific stocks can provide individual investors an edge. Research indicates that shadowing the top stock picks of successful hedge funds can significantly outpace traditional market performance. Our quarterly newsletter has selected an average of 14 small-cap and large-cap stocks per quarter, yielding an impressive 373.4% return since May 2014—outperforming benchmarks by 218 percentage points.
Spotlight on Maplebear Inc. (NASDAQ:CART)
As the final stock reviewed that evening, Maplebear Inc. (CART) had a rocky road ahead despite reporting a strong quarter. Initial optimism surrounded its significant earnings beat, with the company posting 43 cents per share against analyst expectations of a loss. However, the stock’s performance raised eyebrows—Cramer expressed his apprehension:
"I’m just not sure how the grocery delivery space is going to work out in the long run… I think they have the horses to do it [Amazon’s new grocery service]. It’s still too early for me to get behind this one."
Interestingly, despite Cramer’s cautious stance, CART stock rose 27.51% over the following twelve months. It’s essential to remember that while Cramer’s insights provide valuable context, the market often has a mind of its own.
Beyond Maplebear: The AI Investment Options
While CART shows potential, we believe certain AI stocks exhibit even greater promise for investors aiming for higher returns in shorter timeframes. One AI stock has posted gains year-to-date, unlike many others losing approximately 25%. For those interested in scouting undervalued opportunities, we offer insights on a cheapest AI stock trading at less than five times its earnings.
Final Thoughts
Maplebear Inc. serves as a compelling case study on the swift fluctuations of the stock market, even when propelled by seemingly favorable news. As you consider potential investments, remember the wisdom Jim Cramer shared: the longer you stay invested, the better your chances for financial growth.
Explore our recommendations on the 20 Best AI Stocks To Buy Now and 30 Best Stocks to Buy According to Billionaires for further insights.
Disclosure
This article was originally published at Insider Monkey.
Stay updated with us at Extreme Investor Network for comprehensive analysis and investment strategies designed for the discerning investor.